MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/related; boundary="----=_NextPart_01DA02E6.6C6AC080" This document is a Single File Web Page, also known as a Web Archive file. If you are seeing this message, your browser or editor doesn't support Web Archive files. Please download a browser that supports Web Archive. ------=_NextPart_01DA02E6.6C6AC080 Content-Location: file:///C:/14635A33/DordoyeNMJ64No4Page503.htm Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/html; charset="windows-1252"
Perception of Alcohol Use and Alcohol Use Disorder among Perso=
ns
Involved in Road Accidents at an Emergency Department: A Cross-Sectional Study *Eugene Kobla Dordoye1, Kwame Affr=
am2
Frempomaa Danso1
1Department of Psychological Medicine and Mental Health, School=
of
Medicine, University of Health and Allied Sciences, Ghana. 2St. Joseph Health Regional
Hospital, Bryan, Texas, USA 3=
School of
Medical Sciences, University of Cape Coast, Ghana 4School of Medicine & Heal=
th
Sciences, Central University, Ghana
Background
Alcohol plays a significant role in road
traffic accidents in Ghana. However, little is known about the perspectives=
of
victims who suffer road traffic accidents, RTAs, and the extent to which
alcohol use disorder is involved.
Methodology
We conducted a three-month cross-sectional
study in a teaching hospital involving 102 patients involved in a road acci=
dent
and presented to the hospital’s emergency. The Alcohol Use Disorder
Identification Test, AUDIT, was used to assess for Alcohol Use Disorder, AU=
D,
at a score of 8. In addition, we used open-ended questionnaires to assess t=
heir
perception of alcohol use and road accidents.
Results
Of the 102 respondents, 75% were males, a=
nd
60% were between 15 and 35 years old. About 69% of respondents admitted to
using alcohol, while 31%, including a single female, screened positive for
alcohol use disorder. A significant majority of about 90% of respondents
believed in some myths of alcohol use in Ghana, and a similar percentage we=
re
aware of the risks alcohol use posed to road use. Over 30% of respondents,
mainly drivers or riders, had used alcohol within 12 hours of the accident.=
All
but three respondents knew alcohol-induced aggression and poor coordination=
of
movements. A similar number of respondents knew alcohol made people cross r=
oads
carelessly and were hyperactive or disinhibited.
Conclusion
Alcohol use and alcohol use disorder are
significantly high among persons presenting with RTA to the emergency.
Knowledge of the deleterious effects of alcohol is high, yet their behavior=
did
not reflect the knowledge. Therefore, a significant reduction in RTA can be
achieved by enforcing blood alcohol concentration limits for road users and
intensive education to the populace.
Keywords: Alcohol=
Use
Disorder, Identification Test, Emergency Department, Ghana, Myths of=
Alcohol =
Use,
Road Accidents.
=
=
*Correspondence Dr Eugene K Dordoye
Department of Psychological Medicine and Ment=
al
Health, School of Medicine, University of Health and Allied Sciences, Ghana=
. Email: edordoye@uhas.edu.gh=
This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed und=
er
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-Share Alike 4.0
License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-c=
ommercially,
as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed u=
nder
the identical terms.
How to cite this article: Dordoye EK, Affram K,
Introduction
Road
traffic accidents (RTA) are a significant public health concern, claiming 1=
.35
million global lives annually1. In Ghana, more than three lives =
are
lost daily due to RTAs 2. The factors leading to RTAs vary widely
worldwide, with alcohol use and distracted driving ranking high in developed
countries like the USA 3, 4. The poor state of roads and vehicles
and driver carelessness contribute significantly to RTAs. Alcohol consumpti=
on
by road users significantly contributes to carelessness, distraction, and
delayed response time to emergencies, making it one of the significant
preventable factors to consider in RTA5-7.
Studies
using breathalyzers revealed that up to 21% of drivers in relatively more
prosperous southern Ghana and 9.3% in the relatively poorer northern Ghana
tested positive for alcohol5,8. Furthermore, another study in the
Upper West Region of Ghana (also in the north) noted that 34% of road users,
including drivers, pedestrians, and passengers, involved in RTAs had detect=
able
alcohol in their blood 9. Thus suggesting that the role alcohol
plays in motor vehicle accidents in Ghana is quite significant.
Education would be a key
component in an attempt to intervene in the impact of alcohol on RTA on the
Ghanaian population. A previous study suggests that only 4% of drivers knew=
the
legal limits of blood alcohol concentration10. Thus far, it is
unknown whether drivers and road users understand the extent to which alcoh=
ol
can alter their abilities and increase the risk of accidents. Understanding=
the
perceptions of alcohol users on the effect of alcohol on RTAs would be
necessary for tailoring and administering interventions that can reduce the
rate of RTAs. In addition, it will be essential to identify persons with al=
cohol
use disorder (AUD) who, despite knowing the effects of alcohol on road usag=
e,
will still go ahead and risk it. Such persons should be the focus of
tailor-made interventions where possible.
In this study, we assessed the
perceptions of persons involved in RTA and presenting to the emergency of Ho
Teaching Hospital, a new teaching hospital in Ho municipality. The municipa=
lity
has about 220,000 people on 164,000 sq km of land11. The primary
means of transport are taxis, mini-buses, and, in the past few years, motor=
ized
cycle rickshaws, which have become most people’<=
/span>s primary means of
transport. Motorized cycle rickshaws have become the primary means of trans=
port
outside Ghana’s first two cities (Acc=
ra
and Kumasi). They are popularly referred to as Kɛ=
span>kɛ=
span> in Ho an=
d Pragia=
span> or Aboboya in other municipalities in the
country.
We also assessed them for AUD
using the Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Test (AUDIT) in the responden=
ts
to determine the extent to which extra intervention may be warranted in red=
ucing
alcohol-related RTAs.
Methodology <=
b>
A cross-sectional survey was
conducted over three months, from May to July 2021. Information was obtained
from road users involved in RTAs presenting to the Emergency Department (ED=
) of
the regional hospital in the Volta region of Ghana.
We included all 102 persons
between the ages of 15 and 60 who presented with RTA for the duration of the
study. The Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Test (AUDIT) was used to ass=
ess
alcohol use disorder (AUD) among respondents. A score of 8 or more out of a
maximum score of 40 was associated with AUD. A score of 8 gives the maximum
AUROC [area under the ROC (Receiver Operational and Characteristic - graph =
of
sensitivity against 1 - specificity curve)] and was used to screen persons =
with
AUD12. Also, open-ended questionna=
ires
were used to generate responses on their perceptions of alcohol use and
knowledge of AUD. We used thematic analysis to group the responses for the
following results.
Results
The ratio of males to females=
who
presented with RTA was 3:1, and over 70% of the respondents were aged betwe=
en
15 and 35. This age group was also more likely to have AUD, with 56.3% being
positive. Of the 32 respondents who screened positive for AUD, only one was
female. About 19% of respondents admitted taking alcohol within 12 hours of=
the
RTA, and 67% of respondents who had taken alcohol in the preceding 12 hours
were either a driver or K=
ɛkɛ rider. Thus, those who had m=
ore
control to prevent an RTA were more likely to be impaired by alcohol use th=
an
their passengers who had little control.
Perception of Alcohol
Consumption:
Almost all respondents (98%)
agreed they consume alcohol to enhance sociability, increase work performan=
ce,
and boost confidence. In addition, 55.9% of the respondents noted that they
consume alcohol to escape personal issues, while 15.7% simply consumed it to
get drunk. However, almost all (94.1%) had some myths or misperceptions of
alcohol use, such as use for medicinal purposes or to improve appetite, sim=
ilar
to misperceptions found among engineering workers in Ghana13. Most responde=
nts,
91.1%, agreed that they consume alcohol for enjoyment, while 87.3% agreed t=
hat
they consume alcohol to deal with fear.
Perception of Alcohol-Induced
Behavior:
About 97% of the respondents =
were
aware that alcohol causes people to be aggressive and induces poor coordina=
tion
of movements. Furthermore, over 83% agreed that alcohol causes loss of
consciousness, while 95.1% noted that it causes drowsiness and inattention.
Also, more than 95% said alcohol causes people to cross busy roads careless=
ly,
while 94.1% stated it causes hyperactivity or disinhibition. Finally, 89.2%
noted that alcohol causes poor vision.
Discussion
It has been previously noted =
that
alcohol use contributes significantly to traffic accidents in Ghana. Besides
the poor nature of roads and inadequate maintenance of some vehicles, alcoh=
ol
use can contribute to almost all factors that increase the risk of RTA,
including distracted driving, nonadherence to traffic rules and regulations,
and overspeeding10.
An essential step in mitigati=
ng
the role of alcohol in RTAs is the education of the masses. A good
understanding of the perceptions of victims of road traffic accidents who h=
ave
used alcohol will help develop practical educational tools to prevent RTAs.
Also, identifying people with alcohol use disorder can help prevent recurre=
nt
offending.
Alcohol consumption resulting=
in
RTAs was more rampant among drivers under 35 than those older, with a male
preponderance. This is consistent with the study in Accra by Mock et al. 8, 9. The preponderance of young
adult males in alcohol-related RTAs was further reflected in the high
prevalence of alcohol use disorder among them. AUDIT assessment revealed th=
at
56% of young drivers under 35 had alcohol use disorder, of which 96% were m=
ale.
The estimated rate of AUD in the Ghanaian population is 7.3%; thus, a 56% r=
ate
among drivers involved in RTAs in the municipality suggests a disproportion=
ally
high rate.
To develop practical educatio=
nal
tools, we thought it essential to know why respondents drank before using t=
he
roads. Most respondents claimed they consumed alcohol to improve their
sociability and confidence levels. Some said they drank to deal with fear a=
nd
improve their appetite. These responses are consistent with the general the=
ory
for reasons for alcohol use, mainly social and coping with stress
Prevention or significant
reduction of avoidable deaths, injuries, and disabilities can be prevented =
by
enforcing the regulation on blood alcohol concentration, BAC, limits (of 80=
mg
alcohol per 100ml of blood or 0.08% BAC in Ghana)16. This can be achieved at a lower cost if the police do random
checks on the road with Breathalyzers just as they check the roadworthiness=
of
vehicles.
When assessed on the implicat=
ions
of alcohol use, it was apparent that many of the respondents did know the
deleterious effects of alcohol on driving, including increased aggressivene=
ss,
hyperactivity, loss of consciousness, and poor vision. Thus, they drink alc=
ohol
and drive despite their knowledge of its deleterious effects. This construes
high levels of AUD among the respondents, as noted in the AUDIT evaluations.
Policies for implementing screening and brief interventions may be necessar=
y to
reduce alcohol use among this population and hopefully reduce RTA recurrence
rates.
Because AUD would require
intervention beyond education, more extensive studies, including multicenter
studies, will be needed to assess the extent of AUD among drivers involved =
in
RTAs and the appropriate interventions proposed. Also, efforts should be ma=
de
for future studies to utilize breathalyzers and actual blood alcohol levels=
to
have more objective measurements of alcohol use.
Conclusions
Persons involved in RTAs who =
have
consumed alcohol were predominantly young males, with a significant proport=
ion
of them most likely having AUD. Over 90% of respondents know the harmful ef=
fects
of alcohol and the risks it poses to them when using the road, yet they took
it. Knowledge of the deleterious effects of alcohol is high, yet their behaviour did not reflect the knowledge. Reduction in=
road
accidents can be achieved by enforcing blood alcohol concentration limits f=
or
road users and intensive education of road users.
References
1. Toroyan=
T. Global status rep=
ort
on road safety. Inj Prev 2009;15(4):286 -.
2. Konlan KD, Doat AR,
Mohammed I, Amoah RM, Saah JA, Abdulai JA. Prevalence and pattern of road
traffic accidents among Commercial Motorcyclists in the Central Tongu District, Ghana. Scientific
World Journal. 2020;9493-7=
18
3. &n=
bsp;
Mobile dev=
ice
use while driving--United States and seven European countries, 2011. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep.
2013;62(10):177-82.=
5. &n=
bsp;
Damsere<=
/span>-Derry J, Palk G, King=
M.
Prevalence of alcohol-impaired driving and riding in Northern Ghana. Traffic Inj Prev. 2016;17(3):226-32. Epub 20150706=
span>
6. &n=
bsp;
Gyimah N. Contributing
Factors to Road Accidents in Ghana. Mathews Journal of
Emergency Medicine. 2021;8(1).=
7. &n=
bsp;
Poku SA, Bandoh DA, Kenu E, Kploanyi EE, Addo-Lartey AA. Factors contributing to =
road
crashes among commercial vehicle drivers in the Kintampo North Municipality,
Ghana, in 2017. Ghana Med J. 2020;<=
span
class=3DHyperlink1>54(3):132-9.
8. &n=
bsp;
Mock C, Asiamah, Godfiied., Amegashie, Jus=
tice.
Epidemiology of Alcohol-Impaired Driving in an African Nation. Journal of C=
rash
Prevention and Injury Control. 2001;=
2
9. &n=
bsp;
Damsere<=
/span>-Derry J, Palk G, King=
M.
Prevalence of alcohol among nonfatally injured road accident casualties in
two-level III trauma centers in northern Ghana. Traffic Inj Prev. 2018;
10. Damsere-Derry J, Palk G, King M. Motorists’ knowledge, attitudes a=
nd practices
toward alcohol-impaired driving/riding in Ghana. Traffic Inj Prev=
. 2017;<=
span
class=3DNone>18(1):28-34.
11. Legislative Instrument.
2020 LI 2397. Ho Municipal Assembly, Ghana.
12. Dordoye EK, Asare JB, Prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorder Among Worker=
s. Postgraduate Medical Journal of Ghana. 2021; =
10(2):98-101
13. Dordoye EK, Aku TMA, Avle TDA,
and Dziwornu E. The Myths of Alcohol Use in Gha=
na. Postgraduate Medical Journal of Ghana. 2023 Mar 15=
span>; 12(1):20-2
14. Abbey A, Smith M. The
relationship between the reason for drinking alcohol and alcohol consumptio=
n:
An interactional approach. Addict Behav. 2015;<=
span
class=3DHyperlink1>45:93-98
15. Fell JC, Scolese J, Achoki T, Burk=
s C,
Goldberg A, DeJong W. The effectiveness of alternative transportation progr=
ams
in reducing impaired driving: A literature review and synthesis. J Safety Res.2020; 75:128-39. Epub
20200921.
16. Road Traffic Act (Act
683). Section 10 (b). Republic of Ghana.
= =
Dordoye EK, et al - Perception of Alcohol Use and
Alcohol Use Disorder